Vanilla Bean Cupcakes with Silky Vanilla Bean Frosting

Please update your Google Reader! http://feeds.feedburner.com/howsweeteats/smSp

I’m a bit scatter-brained when it comes to baking. Sometimes I’ll see a photo and want to recreate it, other times an idea simply pops into my head.

One constant, though: I almost never have butter sitting out. Do you struggle with this too?

Since I go through what feels like tons of butter every week, it’s often stashed in the freezer. That creates a problem when a recipe calls for softened butter—because patience isn’t my strong suit.

Martha Stewart suggests slicing butter into 1/4-inch pieces and letting it sit for 10 minutes. That works if your house is warm and you have time. In my cold house, with my lack of patience, that method has failed me more than once.

Thankfully, Mother Lovett taught me a trick: microwave the butter in short bursts. Six seconds is the magic number. Not four, not seven—six. Heat for six seconds, check, and repeat until soft. It sounds tedious, but it’s quick and effective.

Different microwaves behave differently, though. Mine is loud and hot, so I only microwave for three seconds at a time. It’s repetitive, but better than having to wait hours for butter to soften.

Sugar ready, I got to work. I love vanilla beans and the aroma and flavor they add to baking.

I scraped every bit of vanilla from the pod—I felt justified after spending my life savings on it. Totally worth it.

The batter came together creamy and fluffy.

Then my husband committed the ultimate sin: he bought low-fat buttermilk. Horrors. (I tease—maybe he was sending a subtle message.)

The cupcakes looked perfect straight out of the oven—full, fluffy, and the ideal size. I left them to cool while I finished eating, then returned to find they had collapsed.

I had improvised the recipe a bit and wasn’t sure what went wrong, but judging by the number of cupcakes and how they fell, I suspected I’d added too much milk.

Rather than give up, I made them again. This time I used regular milk—actually organic skim—and reduced the amount. The cupcakes turned out perfectly.

Lesson learned: don’t test a recipe using an expensive vanilla bean unless you’re okay with risking it. But when it works, the results are worth it.

Look at those specks of vanilla.

My husband wouldn’t even try one—he says he prefers regular vanilla. To me, vanilla bean and vanilla extract are both lovely; I don’t get how someone could prefer one so strongly over the other. It seems almost mental.

With the cupcakes fixed, I moved on to frosting. I made a simple buttercream and added more vanilla bean for flavor and those delightful black specks.

I adore those specks—the frosting even had a subtle pearlescent sheen. When I was a teen I used to wake early, scoop a small bowl of vanilla bean ice cream, stir it until it was soft-serve, and eat it while watching cartoons. Yes, I was way past being six or seven.

Want a taste? If you’re attending Good Taste Pittsburgh, you’ll get to try this cupcake—come say hello!

Stay tuned for a delicious giveaway.

Become a How Sweet fan on Facebook!