Top Recipe Disasters of 2012: Kitchen Fails and Fixes

Okay, people. I’m officially calling 2012 the year of recipe disasters. It was a rough one.

2010 was… whatever.

2011 was kind of rough.

This year? Ouch.

I had more failed recipes come out of my kitchen in the last 12 months than ever before. Maybe it was because I’ve gotten more comfortable — you know, the “I don’t have to measure anything ever” approach — or because I got overly ambitious and wanted to try new things. Probably both. And sure, some failures were born of laziness, desperation, or plain hunger.

Some weeks it felt like I made four or five disasters in a row. Do you want to hear about them? Probably not. Too bad — I’m telling you anyway.

img 29942 1

In January I attempted a chocolate peanut butter sheet cake. It was awful — almost no flavor, and I think I burned the peanut butter while melting it and used it anyway. Have you ever tasted burnt peanut butter? Don’t. Still, I attacked that cake with a fork a few times. I live a sad life.

Moving on.

img 29942 2

I made some kind of chicken in a green-chili sauce that looked and tasted absolutely horrific. I had no idea what I was doing — truly terrible. I wouldn’t wish that on anyone. Well, maybe on my worst enemy.

In the spring I went on a serious blue corn chip kick. If that sounds like everyday behavior for me, you’re right. I was so obsessed I put blue corn into everything.

img 29942 3

Example #1: blue corn cakes. They were not good — pretty hideous, actually. I also made blueberry butter using frozen berries because I was lazy; the result was a separated dark purple mess. Awesome.

img 29942 4

Example #2: blue corn chip–crusted chicken fingers. Not nearly as tasty as I hoped. I was aiming for something as great as a salt-and-vinegar crusted fish I’d made before, but this fell flat. Also, the pictures of bluish-purple-brownish chicken were totally unappealing.

Apparently failures came in twos this year. Or I was just super forgetful. Probably the latter.

img 29942 5

I tried lavender cinnamon rolls with chocolate ganache and they were a disaster. It wasn’t the lavender-chocolate combo that bothered me — that can be great — it was the whole wheat cinnamon roll base. Certain things should not be made with whole wheat flour; cinnamon rolls are one of them.

Not learning my lesson, I later made whole wheat apple cider cinnamon rolls. The photos you see are from the third failed batch.

img 29942 6

What’s the definition of insanity? My picture will probably be right underneath.

Here’s how not to cook shrimp:

img 29942 7

Don’t try to make a lightened-up sweet-and-sour shrimp and end up with rubbery pieces that only taste of soy sauce and vinegar. This shrimp tasted like it had taken a six-hour vinegar bath. I hated it.

This mango coconut chicken looked promising but was extremely bland and covered in an unappetizing electric yellow mango sauce. It was acidic and unbalanced — sounded good, but in practice, no.

img 29942 8

Want a glimpse of what my life looks like most weeks?

img 29942 9

Yeah. That.

Sometimes things turn out okay-ish, or at least edible.

img 29942 10

In September I made chocolate cupcakes and one of the worst pumpkin buttercreams I’ve seen. My decorating skills were also pathetic — I still lack patience.

Remember when I made glazed donut holes I loved? The first batch looked like little lumps of coal, but they were tasty enough.

img 29942 11

Two nights ago I tried to recreate my grandmother’s orange cookies at midnight. That attempt didn’t turn out at all — they weren’t cookies.

img 29942 12

So yeah — that’s probably about an eighth of the disasters that came out of my kitchen this year. These are some of my favorites — at least the ones I photographed instead of throwing a tantrum and tossing the tray. Even when I was in full meltdown mode, looking back I appreciate these failures because I assume I learned something from them. Right? That sounds mature. Or old. Maybe I’m growing up. I hope not.

Here’s to more patience in 2013.